After today’s class, I began to think about the question
that was raised: “Why didn’t Mr. Rochester divorce Bertha?” I was curious as to
what the divorce laws in the 19th century were.
·
For a male to get a divorce, he had to say that
his wife had committed adultery. I think
that it would be challenging for Mr. Rochester to say that Bertha was being
unfaithful. Because she is locked up, Bertha does not have the opportunity to
have an affair.
·
Here is a little side note about divorce laws in
the 19th century. Women had a
much harder time obtaining a divorce. Unlike men, women had to prove that her
husband had been unfaithful. In an era with zero technology, proving adultery
would be quite difficult. In addition, a
woman had to prove that her husband was committing incest, cruelty, bigamy, or desertion. Men, however, were not
expected to be faithful. It was socially acceptable for a man to have a
mistress or a brothel.
I find the idea of "moral insanity" in the Stanford article particularly provoking. For me, it begs analysis of Rochester's place on the shared spectrum of mental health and moral goodness.
ReplyDelete"Charlotte’s idea of “moral insanity,” upon which she formed the character of Bertha, was not her own; James Cowles Pritchard defined this concept in 1835 as a type of madness characterized by “a morbid perversion of the natural feelings, affections, inclinations, temper, habits, moral dispositions, and natural impulses, without any remarkable disorder or defect of the intellect, or knowing and reasoning faculties, and particularly without any insane illusion or hallucination.”
Another part of the Stanford article that I find to be interesting is this quote: "Women were thought to be more susceptible than men to such disorders and could even inherit them. Sexual appetite was considered one of the chief symptoms of moral insanity in women; it was subject to severe sanctions and regarded as abnormal or pathological."
ReplyDeleteSo, if a woman is interested in sex, then she is insane?
These discussions of what is considered to be moral insanity make me question whether or not Bertha really is insane. If a man married me and then locked me away, I would probably consider setting his room on fire as well.
As I mentioned in class, I am grateful that you took the initiative to research/post this!
ReplyDelete